Quote:
Originally Posted by dancey
If you go by that methodology, then things like "Arrange Version", "TV-Edit", "Karaoke" etc don't belong in the title because they're just information, not a name.
|
That's a retarded comparison because things like "Arrange Version", "TV-Edit", "Karaoke" literally describe a version of a song while things like "Stage1", "Event Scene", "FinalBoss" describe an area in a game. They're two totally different things and I don't know why you're trying to compare them, it's just bad logic. Take
Hatenkou Yuugi, for example. There are 6 different versions of "Take you as you are", each with the style of the version, like "Original", "Sentimental", etc. If we remove those, we have "Take you as you are" written out 6 times, with no difference in the track titles, even though they're clearly not the same track. However, if we remove the game information from the track titles on this soundtrack, then it doesn't change shit, does it?
Quote:
Originally Posted by dancey
If you apply your same methodology to album titles, then we shouldn't include "single / artist" for all the singles like "blah blah / ayumi hamasaki".
|
You're absolutely correct, we shouldn't. Just because we 100% do something at this point in time doesn't mean we're doing it correctly, why do you think we still have guideline discussions? Thank you for making the suggestion to change this as well.