Quote:
Originally Posted by Guitarist500
Besaid Island's re-arrangement is more creatively arranged than the original which felt repetitive and didn't seem to fit the area well compared to the re-arrangement,
|
Well, we're just in the realm of personal taste here. I think the original is much more creative, while the new one sounds like Asian muzak.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Guitarist500
yet people insist the outdated original is better.
|
You lost me here. In what sense is it "outdated"? The original track could have been released today.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Guitarist500
What do you guys want? Faithful re-mastering or re-arrangements that are different in a good way?
|
Not sure who you're addressing here. Nobody's expressing contradictory wants, and most people would probably have been happy with no changes to the music.
Personally, if you're going to re-arrange a piece, the only thing I care about is whether it's a good arrangement. I doubt anyone's any different.