Quote:
Originally Posted by Cedille
It's definitely nice to have some dedicated classifications to albums and media (I also propose we turn Live Event and Video into such), but once we classify one album or disc as Vocal Album, would it basically stay as Vocal Album alone? Or, do these album-specific classifications stay together with the other ones we use for individual tracks? I imagine either way can potentially be problematic.
|
I envisioned that sometimes, an album might be "mostly vocal", but have a drama track or something else, so we would need to mix these album/disc type classifications with the track-based ones.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cedille
I think it would be better to not limit these classifications to vocals only, as OP/ED/Theme song can sometimes be instrumental only (like this). Also, I think a trailer theme is akin to a commercial song (but tend to be instrumental only), so I feel it should be covered by Character/Image/Commercial Song. |
One problem there is that Character Theme BGM (say Tifa's theme from FF7) could also fall into this classification. Maybe this is an argument not to call it Character. Just make it Commercial/Image.