View Single Post
  #4  
Old Nov 7, 2009, 03:08 PM
Metroid's Avatar
Metroid Metroid is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: UK
Posts: 231
Default

All Right, It looks like EAC detected the thing.

Code:
  

TOC of the extracted CD

     Track |   Start  |  Length  | Start sector | End sector 
    ---------------------------------------------------------
        1  |  0:00.00 |  3:20.19 |         0    |    15018   
        2  |  3:20.19 |  4:08.35 |     15019    |    33653   
        3  |  7:28.54 |  4:39.40 |     33654    |    54618   
        4  | 12:08.19 |  2:32.35 |     54619    |    66053   
        5  | 14:40.54 |  2:05.63 |     66054    |    75491   
        6  | 16:46.42 |  4:23.38 |     75492    |    95254   
        7  | 21:10.05 |  1:34.35 |     95255    |   102339   
        8  | 22:44.40 |  5:18.09 |    102340    |   126198   
        9  | 28:02.49 |  3:43.28 |    126199    |   142951   
       10  | 31:46.02 |  4:06.47 |    142952    |   161448   
       11  | 35:52.49 |  6:12.56 |    161449    |   189404   
       12  | 42:05.30 |  5:22.05 |    189405    |   213559   
       13  | 47:27.35 |  4:34.00 |    213560    |   234109   
       14  | 52:01.35 |  4:33.08 |    234110    |   254592   
       15  | 56:34.43 |  5:03.57 |    254593    |   277374   
       16  | 64:10.25 |  0:13.56 |    288775    |   289805
Track 16 is not detected as being a track but it appears as a data track. Do I get the freedb info via EAC if the data track is 15 no. Do I get the info if the data track is 16 tracks yes. Now which one is right? since the ACC database has the disc as having 15 tracks not as 16 tracks?

It seems when the data track is at the end of the disc things work or bug differently or maybe EAC has a detection bug concerning some data tracks and the Accurate-rip DB goes along the same way. That is the reason why the DiscID is in the ACC database.

EAC does not rip data tracks unless I'm missing something. I need to use isoBuster to do that and leave it as a data track.

The good thing is the experience we gained here.

I fixed the other tracklist and set it to default.

I was thinking about, maybe we could leave both tracklists, for example my case, why should I keep the data track since is not a track after I ripped the disc? Leaving both tracklist online here at VGMdb means that I could rely on the second tracklist that does not contain the data track to retrieve the info from VGMdb Freedb. We could add that functionality for cases like this one. Tracklists with data tracks and tracklists without data tracks, that would be a great feature.

The tracklist without data tracks could be named as English NDT = "No Data Tracks".

Last edited by Metroid; Nov 7, 2009 at 03:51 PM.
Reply With Quote