The problem that I see with toplists, and even moreso, the review prompting is that, aside from the ANONYMITY COMPROMISED, I think it will *really* cut down on the people who want to vote because it will just make voting more of a pain.
You're basically suggesting a more exclusive voting system, and while you think it may improve sportsmanship, it helps the site less. If less people want to deal with the hassle of voting, then less people will vote, and will attract less people to the community.
It's kind of like saying "I don't trust these people, so let's exclude them from the community to keep what's here safe," and I don't think that's the type of attitude that Quintin wants for the site.
Not only that, but if we're narrowing down the voters so that the entrants make up a larger majority of the voters, and they're not able to vote for their own songs, either, I think accuracy will go down along that path.
I've always gotta be the dick.
|