VICL-61320: MADLAX O.S.T.2

[Lowe]

Need help with the Musicians again. Booklet 07.

I figure this is as good a time as any to bring this up.

When you see 'All music and arrangements by xx" does that qualify them to be put in the arranged field? Ira brought this up the other week, he said the arranged field should only be used for other people arranging someones work. Which I tend to agree with.

[Revoc]

Originally Posted by Lowe

Need help with the Musicians again. Booklet 07.

Done!

Originally Posted by Lowe

When you see 'All music and arrangements by xx" does that qualify them to be put in the arranged field? Ira brought this up the other week, he said the arranged field should only be used for other people arranging someones work. Which I tend to agree with.

I disagree. Most albums of the database were classified in this way and I think it would cause confusion if we don't follow the information provided by the booklet and all the japanese sites, like Joshinweb, Jbook and others.

[Lowe]

Thanks again Revoc.

Hrm, that makes sense. Perhaps what Ira was talking about was albums that didn't have 'arranged by' in the booklet, yet people put them in the arranged field. I have a terrible memory.

[Revoc]

Originally Posted by Lowe

Thanks again Revoc.

Hrm, that makes sense. Perhaps what Ira was talking about was albums that didn't have 'arranged by' in the booklet, yet people put them in the arranged field. I have a terrible memory.

My pleasure. If this is what he said I agree with Ira.