35C35-7154: Roman Trip GUIN SAGA ~Henkyou-hen~ (reprint)

[Phonograph]

this album needs to become parent, please

[Myrkul]

What's up with Guin Saga ..?
Do we really need this in the database ?

[Phonograph]

no, delete them if that pleases you

[depa]

why don't readd this to the database? it'a a novel graphich and we have some of them in the database

[Yahagi93]

I agree the albums should be readded plus I have additional information to add for them.

[Phonograph]

(the deleter) didn't get my sarcasm ;p

[Yahagi93]

Well that's why it got deleted in the end because you were sarcastic. If you want something to stay on the database you gotta fight for it and stand your ground, not be sarcastic about it. That won't get you anywhere. I'm sorry for the call out but it needed to be said I think.

[Illidan]

The albums aren't deleted by the way, they're just hidden.
We generally don't allow albums from novel franchises unless there's a relevant artist, although as depa said we aren't very consistent with the rule.
In this case I think the issue was with the sheer amount of albums (27 counting reprints, probably missing quite a few) that didn't really fit in the database.

I don't believe the rules changed since they were disabled, but you might try asking Secret Squirrel about it.

[Phonograph]

sarcasm is my religion, can't live without =)
it pisses off a lot of people irl and I like that ;p

[Yahagi93]

I already sent him a message this morning so we'll see.

[RomanticScent]

I think the albums should be on here since we now a considerable amount of composers from those.

[Yahagi93]

All of the albums were by Goro Ohmi, whom I don't know if he's considered a relevant composer here. He did do 4 Digital Trips and a few anime OSTs and image albums. We could make a compromise where we just keep the first 5 Guin Saga albums (1983-1986) since those were actually Roman Trips, but the other 7 albums made in the 90s (1993-1997) we can drop since those are not Roman Trips and are merely image albums.

[depa]

But if we accept for example osts from movies sharing the same name (street fighter, resident evil, etc) so we can't left them. Are they or not VISUAL ARTS? Don't remember the subtitle of the name of this site? Iread VISUAL ARTS and a manga, a novel are VISUAL ARTS. that's my opinion

[RomanticScent]

that is why he considered the roman trips only. Since we kinda have a database for digital trips and jam trips, we could build database for roman trip too.

[Yahagi93]

Oh no I agree with you depa I totally want all 12 Guin Saga albums on here. The compromise thing I said earlier was just a suggestion. It's up to the admins though.

[Secret Squirrel]

I don't really have any coherent argument on keeping these hidden anymore. They are mostly accurate and complete, so I've brought them all back into public view.

[RomanticScent]

LONG LIVE SS!!!!!

[Phonograph]

(you didn't dare a sieg heil ;p)

[Illidan]

I set the LPs as parents where appropriate, I think. If I missed anything leave a post here.

EDIT: artist names are fine if they are credited in English on the LPs, otherwise please add the Kanji next to them (or make a new artist entry so we can link them).

If the english subtitles are official please provide a source so we can check, and if they are they should be added to all the reprints as well, but on the 4th line not the 3rd (that's for romaji when needed).

[Yahagi93]

I have scans for the 1st CD prints of Senran Hen, Graffiti, and Shichinin no Madoushi so hopefully that will help. For Graffiti and Shichinin no Madoushi, the tracklisting is listed in English on the back so I just copied those.

Thanks for your help Illidan

[depa]

do you have a readable back cover without Obi of CX-7217 Senran LP?
I can't read half of performers credit

Originally Posted by Illidan

I set the LPs as parents where appropriate, I think. If I missed anything leave a post here.

EDIT: artist names are fine if they are credited in English on the LPs, otherwise please add the Kanji next to them (or make a new artist entry so we can link them).

If the english subtitles are official please provide a source so we can check, and if they are they should be added to all the reprints as well, but on the 4th line not the 3rd (that's for romaji when needed).

For Kanji character we need Insert scans to check or Back scans of the cassette release

[Illidan]

This is a bit small but should be readable: http://auction.thumbnail.image.rakut...0049716436.jpg

Conductor is Katsuaki Nakatani and Concertmaster Akira Uchida.

[depa]

Great!!
Another question: is Big Mouth a group formed only for these albums?
Should we link any performer of these album to this unit group as members?

[Yahagi93]

I haven't heard Big Mouth anywhere else so I think they were formed just for Guin Saga, same with Great Madoh Orchestra. As for "His Satanic Orchestra" from Shichinin no Madoushi, I think that was just thrown on there and doesn't mean anything especially since 90% of that album is just Goro Ohmi on snythesizers and there's almost no symphonic pieces at all.