VGMdb
Go Back   VGMdb Forums > Discussion > Video Game Music Discussion > Album Discussions
Register FAQ Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #61  
Old Jan 23, 2014, 06:09 PM
_if's Avatar
_if _if is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 379

I would say compositional substance and production/performance/arrangement/etc. substance can be two different things. I haven't heard even a snippet of this soundtrack so I have no opinion about it, but I've read it has a very distinctive sound or tone. Those things are not inherently tied into composition as they can be brought about through means like effects such as reverb, playing piano instead of forte, using a cello instead of a baritone saxophone or something, or choosing a singer with a smooth tone of voice rather than the guy from Pantera. My understanding of TerraEpon's statement is that it's got a nice mood and very pretty dressing on what are rather mundane tunes at the level of writing because they rely heavily on one not especially creative idea.

However, I wouldn't agree with his earlier statement that vocals are part of the composition as the melody sung could have been assigned to something else instead, therefore I'd call it arrangement, so my interpretation could be wrong. I still totally understand something having no compositional substance but still being good ear candy. Often that's where guilty pleasures come from.
Reply With Quote
  #62  
Old Jan 23, 2014, 10:31 PM
TerraEpon's Avatar
TerraEpon TerraEpon is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 584
Default

To put it a different way, it's reletively simple and lacks depth, but complexity and depth are not required for something to be enjoyable. What the music DOES have is color and a unique sound element that make up for it.

Various music is good for different reasons. A ragtime piece might have mostly simple accompaniment but wonderful melodies and delicious harmonies. A solo jazz percussion piece may have rhythmic complexity and color that makes up for the lack of any real pitch. Just a couple of examples.
Reply With Quote
  #63  
Old Nov 16, 2018, 05:05 AM
IJustDontKnowAnymore IJustDontKnowAnymore is online now
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 148
Default

I know that we've got some official credits for who did what based on Automata's OST credits, and through the process of elimination on other NieR releases, but I take it we'll never get actual composer credits for the soundtrack, will we? I'd be really interested to see the credits, so I can't help but ask. I doubt tweeting at the composers will yield a response or anything of that sort either. Would anybody have a way of getting the composer credits for this album?
Reply With Quote
  #64  
Old Jan 2, 2019, 12:20 AM
preta preta is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2017
Posts: 45
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by IJustDontKnowAnymore View Post
I know that we've got some official credits for who did what based on Automata's OST credits, and through the process of elimination on other NieR releases, but I take it we'll never get actual composer credits for the soundtrack, will we? I'd be really interested to see the credits, so I can't help but ask. I doubt tweeting at the composers will yield a response or anything of that sort either. Would anybody have a way of getting the composer credits for this album?
I'd say tweeting at them is definitely worth a try. That's how we've gotten most Falcom composer credits that we have.
Reply With Quote
  #65  
Old Jan 3, 2019, 03:04 PM
IJustDontKnowAnymore IJustDontKnowAnymore is online now
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 148
Default

If I had a twitter account I'd try it then, but I don't and something tells me if I tweet at them with a new account I won't get a response. Anyone else wanna try asking them through twitter?

edit:

So I feel that there are some ways to narrow down the composers for who's done what, and we can do this through the information provided for other releases and comparing the tracks on those releases to the OST. Apart from that we can only assume for some tracks based off of some tracks from Nier Automata, like Wretched Automatons and Wretched Weaponry for example.

Based on the two pre-order bonuses for the Gestalt and Replicant versions in Japan, we know that Keiichi Okabe and Kakeru Ishihama are responsible for the tracks on those releases.

Based on the fact that Okabe is credited to Song of The Ancients (Fate) on Automata I don't think it's a stretch to think he alone composed it, and all versions of it, especially considering he remixed it in the 15 Nightmare's and Arrange Tracks album too. Likewise with the example given above, I feel we can also assume he composed Wretched Automatons.

We also know thanks to Don that Keigo Hoashi composed Shadowlord, it's white-note mix, and some battle themes. Additionally, we also know that Okabe composed Grandma.

It doesn't narrow down a lot, but the credits get a little more narrow based on this, as opposed to just crediting each track to the four composers.

I remember someone posted a composer breakdown they got when they inserted their disc into iTunes, but that couldn't have been accurate, as it'd be available elsewhere and because iTunes just pulls from public databases and has nothing special, right? I don't see any CD text on the disc either, hell, I never see CD text on any OST.

Last edited by IJustDontKnowAnymore; Jan 8, 2019 at 10:37 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #66  
Old Sep 4, 2019, 11:22 AM
Robin's Avatar
Robin Robin is offline
Trusted Editor
VGM Artist
 
Join Date: Jul 2019
Location: France
Posts: 488
Default

From all those informations, can we make a sort of masterpost for every tracks?
Reply With Quote
  #67  
Old Sep 5, 2019, 07:50 PM
IJustDontKnowAnymore IJustDontKnowAnymore is online now
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 148
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fivda View Post
From all those informations, can we make a sort of masterpost for every tracks?
You mean something like this?

Quote:
Composed by:

Disc 1
Track 1, 2, 4 - Keiichi Okabe, Kakeru Ishihama
Track 6-8 - Keiichi Okabe
Track 3, 5, 9-23 - Keiichi Okabe, Kakeru Ishihama, Keigo Hoashi, Takafumi Nishimura

Disc 2:
Track 1, 3, 8, 13 - Keiichi Okabe, Kakeru Ishihama
Track 2, 9 - Keiichi Okabe
Track 4-7, 10-12, 14, 16-19 - Keiichi Okabe, Kakeru Ishihama, Keigo Hoashi, Takafumi Nishimura
Track 15, 20 - Keigo Hoashi
I think I got every track and cross referenced each of them with other releases where the composer credits were given. In my library I've got Ashes of Dreams credited to Okabe alone, but I can't find a source so I think that's just a hunch I had. Maybe one day we can get an official composer breakdown for this album. If you want to start stretching the credits you can also squeeze 2-04 and 2-14 to Keiichi Okabe and Kakeru Ishihama, as one of the two compositions is credited to those two on the mini album releases. Likewise for 1-09 which is an arrangement of 1-02.

Last edited by IJustDontKnowAnymore; Sep 5, 2019 at 08:00 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #68  
Old Sep 6, 2019, 11:52 AM
Robin's Avatar
Robin Robin is offline
Trusted Editor
VGM Artist
 
Join Date: Jul 2019
Location: France
Posts: 488
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by IJustDontKnowAnymore View Post
You mean something like this?



I think I got every track and cross referenced each of them with other releases where the composer credits were given. In my library I've got Ashes of Dreams credited to Okabe alone, but I can't find a source so I think that's just a hunch I had. Maybe one day we can get an official composer breakdown for this album. If you want to start stretching the credits you can also squeeze 2-04 and 2-14 to Keiichi Okabe and Kakeru Ishihama, as one of the two compositions is credited to those two on the mini album releases. Likewise for 1-09 which is an arrangement of 1-02.
Thanks for that. I'm assuming those credits are both for composer AND arranger?

I hope MONACA will do individual credits for vocals soon enough as well, though Emi Evan's voice is easily reckognizable.
Reply With Quote
  #69  
Old Sep 15, 2019, 08:04 PM
IJustDontKnowAnymore IJustDontKnowAnymore is online now
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 148
Default

The credits are for composer only. You can already kinda see who was responsible for the vocals, and from the tracks themselves you listen to see which chorus it was, if it wasn't just Emi Evans in the track.
Reply With Quote
  #70  
Old Jul 5, 2020, 11:27 AM
Kadai's Avatar
Kadai Kadai is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: México
Posts: 123
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by IJustDontKnowAnymore View Post
You mean something like this?



I think I got every track and cross referenced each of them with other releases where the composer credits were given. In my library I've got Ashes of Dreams credited to Okabe alone, but I can't find a source so I think that's just a hunch I had. Maybe one day we can get an official composer breakdown for this album. If you want to start stretching the credits you can also squeeze 2-04 and 2-14 to Keiichi Okabe and Kakeru Ishihama, as one of the two compositions is credited to those two on the mini album releases. Likewise for 1-09 which is an arrangement of 1-02.
For this album, this is the only "real" breakdown that we have, do not? Or there has been some more progress after this all years?
Reply With Quote
  #71  
Old Jul 5, 2020, 07:52 PM
IJustDontKnowAnymore IJustDontKnowAnymore is online now
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 148
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kadai View Post
For this album, this is the only "real" breakdown that we have, do not? Or there has been some more progress after this all years?
Looking at one of the new releases we get narrower composer credits for a few tracks based on the NieR Orchestral Arrangement Special Box Edition. Specifically for The Prestigious Mask and The Ultimate Weapon we now know it's Keiichi Okabe and Kakeru Ishihama. From disc one of the same release we can exclude Takafumi Nishimura from quite a few tracks (specifically Ashes of Dreams and all variations like the Yonah and Dance of the Evanescent tracks, and Gods Bound by Rules). Looking at the Piano Collection we can also exclude Nishimura from the Repose track on disc two. Likewise, looking at the -echo- release we can exclude Nishimura from even more tracks as well. So the new breakdown looks something like this instead now. There are some other releases that might have been helpful, but they've got no proper scans so there's no way to tell if they'd have more composer information.

Quote:
Composed by:

Disc 1
Track 1, 2, 4, 11, 14 - Keiichi Okabe, Kakeru Ishihama
Track 6-8 - Keiichi Okabe
Track 5, 9, 15-19 - Keiichi Okabe, Kakeru Ishihama, Keigo Hoashi, Takafumi Nishimura
Track 3, 10, 12, 13, 20-23 - Keiichi Okabe, Kakeru Ishihama, Keigo Hoashi

Disc 2:
Track 1, 3, 8, 13 - Keiichi Okabe, Kakeru Ishihama
Track 2, 9 - Keiichi Okabe
Track 5, 6, 10 - Keiichi Okabe, Kakeru Ishihama, Keigo Hoashi, Takafumi Nishimura
Track 15, 20 - Keigo Hoashi
Track 4, 7, 11, 12, 14, 16-19 - Keiichi Okabe, Kakeru Ishihama, Keigo Hoashi
I'm interested to hear if anyone thinks a certain composer might've done a certain track or anything like that, or maybe if I got something wrong someone can clarify, like if a track is unaccounted for.

Like I said in my previous post, I feel like we could also credit disc one track 9, City of Commerce, to the same composers as disc one track 2, Hills of Radiant Wind, since it's pretty much an arrangement of it, but I'd want input from others for that one. Apart from glaringly obvious composers credits, like Song of Ancients/Wretched Weaponry being done by Okabe, I've tried to keep the breakdown largely based on the facts based on releases that we've already gotten.

Last edited by IJustDontKnowAnymore; Jul 11, 2020 at 07:49 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #72  
Old Oct 11, 2020, 01:14 PM
grcr grcr is offline
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2020
Posts: 7
Default

If we're looking only for composition credits, there's probably only one "main" composer for each theme that composed the "original" version, though other versions of the same song may have parts composed and arranged by others (as far as I know, the only true joint composition of a main theme in the entire Automata album, or for that matter even their other Yoko Taro games like Drakengard 3 and Sinoalice, is Alien Manifestation by Okabe and Hoashi).

There's also new official playlists for each Monaca composer that includes selected tracks from the original NieR (http://www.monaca.jp/member/). Okabe confirms he was involved in several tracks: Snow in Summer, Blu-bird, Grandma, Wretched Automatons, Gods Bound By Rules, Dark Colossus, Shadowlord's Castle, Song of the Ancients, and Ashes of Dreams. This probably means he was the main composer for these tracks. Some of these were already discussed in this thread, but Snow in Summer, Blu-bird , Gods Bound By Rules and Shadowlord's Castle seem to be new confirmations. Given that Okabe composed Gods Bound By Rules, that also probably means he composed the theme in Temple of Drifting Sands, which is like the companion 'stage' track that shares the opening high-pitched vocal theme. Also Dispossession is the basis for Faltering Prayer in Automata, which is officially credited to Okabe and Hoashi. I'm assuming Hoashi did the Automata arrangements and Okabe composed the primary theme, but this is just a guess.

Ishihama's playlist does not list any NieR tracks, but he has officially been credited with Emil's theme on the Automata soundtrack. While not directly confirmed on any official album, it looks like he composed Kaine's theme in general, and the Kaine / Salvation version in particular, based on his twitter posts (https://twitter.com/MONACA_ishihama/...55277827715073, https://twitter.com/MONACA_ishihama/...62266196631552).

Hoashi's playlist includes only Shadowlord from the original NieR, so does not add new info. But the Orchestral Arrengement Addendum lists Okabe, Ishihama, Hoashi as composers for the 5 NieR songs, of which 4 can already be credited to Okabe and Ishihama, leaving Deep Crimson Foe as likely composed by Hoashi, though probably as a boss-theme counterpart to The Ultimate Weapon.

I also have some additional guesses without official confirmations, but not with very solid reasons. The Ultimate Weapon vaguely sounds like Okabe if you compare it to something like Grandma or Automata's City Ruins (Rays of Light) . Repose has a lot of repeated '4 note sequences', which seems to be a recurring idea in the background arrangement of a lot of known Okabe compositions (from Automata - Alien Manifestation, Peaceful Sleep, Voice of no Return, Fortress of Lies and Weight of the World, as well as the background in This Silence is Mine from Drakengard 3; while it's not confirmed to be Okabe, the theme music in the trailer for NieR:Reincarnation also has this pattern).

For Hills of Radiant Winds and its arrangements (which seem to be City of Commerce and The Lost Forest), I'm guessing the composer is Ishihama, based on what I think are vague similarities in sound to Kaine / Escape and Strumble from Drakengard 3 (I'm not able to narrow down what the similarity is, but they all sound - well - different, compared to typical tracks, probably in the percussion). Also, Emil and Hills of Radiant Winds are in the key of E minor, Kaine switches to E minor halfway through for the second part, and Strumble seems to start off in E minor. The other two versions of Hills are in different keys, so I don't know how much one should read into this. I would also put The Prestigious Mask in the same category of sounding similar to Hills, though it's not the same theme.

For compositions of Nishimura, based on being able to attribute most of the other tracks to other primary composers in the NieR vinyl even with the official evidence already available, if he was the primary composer for any theme in the vinyl album it's most likely Cold Steel Coffin, or maybe Temple of Drifting Sands if it wasn't Okabe. Curiously, both of these tracks seem to have very similar repeating chorus sequences in the background.

It also seems possible for some official album credits to be incorrect. While Ishihama's twitter page does confirm he composed Kaine - which seems to be in the context of its inclusion in the Memories of Puppets concert, at least the VGMdb page for its Blu-ray, which includes Kaine, does not list him as a composer.
Reply With Quote
  #73  
Old Oct 24, 2020, 05:28 PM
grcr grcr is offline
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2020
Posts: 7
Default

Quote:
But the Orchestral Arrengement Addendum lists Okabe, Ishihama, Hoashi as composers for the 5 NieR songs, of which 4 can already be credited to Okabe and Ishihama, leaving Deep Crimson Foe as likely composed by Hoashi, though probably as a boss-theme counterpart to The Ultimate Weapon.
It turns out this logic doesn't work. The orchestral Emil (Addendum version) has a second half that seems to be based more on Automata's Emil (Despair) (including the additional '3rd part' of the vocals), than on Emil / Karma, so Hoashi could have been listed as a composer for this reason as well. That being said, Deep Crimson Foe still might be Hoashi's work based on the way the song sounds (I think there's a case to be made for sounding similar to War and War from Automata).

Quote:
For compositions of Nishimura, based on being able to attribute most of the other tracks to other primary composers in the NieR vinyl even with the official evidence already available, if he was the primary composer for any theme in the vinyl album it's most likely Cold Steel Coffin, or maybe Temple of Drifting Sands if it wasn't Okabe. Curiously, both of these tracks seem to have very similar repeating chorus sequences in the background.
On the other hand, without this piece of information, it seems more reasonable to attribute Cold Steel Coffin to Okabe as the main composer, partly because of the similarity of the piano to Grandma as well as their shared context. There's also similarities to Gods Bound By Rules (including the vocal chorus in Temple of Drifting Sands and being in the key of C minor, a feature shared with Song of the Ancients), as well as Dark Colossus (the occasional use of horns), and resemblances to several other Okabe compositions from Automata and Sinoalice (mostly boss themes). The arrangement also sounds complex enough that there's a chance it could be Hoashi.

Just for the sake of completeness, that leaves two remaining themes without official information about credits or guesses. I think This/His Dream sounds like Ishihama compositions (if the basis of the above guess about Hills and its arrangements isn't completely wrong). For The Incomplete Stone, if we know it's by one of the Monaca composers, I think Okabe's more likely because of the heavy use of the choir. But these guesses are again starting to feel like reading too much into superficial similarities between songs.

Guesses aside, based on IJustDontKnowAnymore's list, the orchestral addendum (and other official credits) and Monaca's playlists, it looks like it's safe to conclude that Nishimura was either the main composer for Cold Steel Coffin or This/His Dream (I hadn't noticed earlier that Temple of Drifting Sands could also be ruled out), or there's the more unusual possibility of only being a co-composer for some track. I couldn't find any other known composition of Nishimura to try to find parallels in how the tracks sound.

It's possible that the v1.22... album will finally come with the full credits as many of the original songs are being rerecorded and rearranged. But it also seems like Square Enix or someone else involved in publishing has the full composer breakdown for each track already, which they've been using in the different album releases over the years, and they don't publish it for other reasons. This might mean that the new album would also have the same type of overall-album-only credits as we've been getting so far, which is hopefully not the case.
Reply With Quote
  #74  
Old Jun 18, 2021, 11:15 PM
Maskad Maskad is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2016
Posts: 60
Default

The (official) English tracklist was pulled from p. 01-02 of the booklet, where it is printed alongside the official Japanese tracklist, which can also be found on the back. To achieve full compliance with the English track names, I changed "remix" to an uppercase "Remix" on M2-20, which was rejected.

I get that titles or parts of titles written in latin letters (at least as long as they aren't just romanizations) are kept as they are in unofficial and literal English tracklist translations. However, this EN tracklist is an official one, that also features changes on title names that already were in English entirely in the JP tracklist, namely M2-16~19.

Therefore either M2-16~19 have got to be changed to get a tracklist that complies to a set of rules consistently or M2-20 has be changed back to get a proper reflection of the official EN tracklist, which was what I was going for and would prefer, but one may disagree.
Reply With Quote
  #75  
Old Jun 19, 2021, 01:37 AM
Efendija's Avatar
Efendija Efendija is offline
VGMdb Staff
 
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: Serbia
Posts: 2,009
Default

You didn't explain your edit. I'm sure it would've been accepted if you did.

Last edited by Efendija; Jun 19, 2021 at 01:39 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #76  
Old Jun 19, 2021, 07:30 AM
Maskad Maskad is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2016
Posts: 60
Default

Yeah, I normally do that, but here I thought it was just a simple fix to bring the tracklist closer to the source (scan). Turned out I was wrong for the reasons described.

I'll try to be even more careful regarding this matter from now on.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Efendija View Post
You didn't explain your edit. I'm sure it would've been accepted if you did.
Reply With Quote
  #77  
Old Jun 19, 2021, 07:48 AM
Secret Squirrel's Avatar
Secret Squirrel Secret Squirrel is offline
VGMdb Administrator
 
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Cleveland, OH
Posts: 8,240
Default

It's kind of a limitation on our end too, for not requiring a comment for tracklist submissions.
Reply With Quote
  #78  
Old Jul 9, 2021, 12:07 PM
Jimi Jimi is offline
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2017
Posts: 9
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew Evenstar View Post
still discovering new songs on this OST that I didn't really notice before that I love now. Just wow. timeless perfection.
I got like 10 NieR CDs.
So many remixes. There are even a few 8-bit chiptunes on a CD that was included with the Japanese Drakengard 3 Special Limited Edition (which I also own, but you can get the CD only from suruga-ya).
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
SQEX-10673: NieR Gestalt & Replicant Orchestral Arrangement Album _if Album Discussions 4 Dec 7, 2018 09:36 PM
SQEX-10612~3: NieR Gestalt & Replicant Original Soundtrack Vinyl franzito Album Discussions 1 Sep 1, 2018 06:45 AM
SQEX-10614~7: NieR:Automata / NieR Gestalt & Replicant Original Soundtrack Vinyl Box Jotamide Album Discussions 2 Dec 20, 2017 04:50 PM
SQEX-10212: NieR Gestalt & Replicant 15 Nightmares & Arrange Tracks Don Album Discussions 9 Jun 20, 2016 09:28 AM
SQEX-10303: Piano Collections NieR Gestalt & Replicant Argentis Album Discussions 15 Mar 24, 2012 12:36 AM