[Edit] FINAL FANTASY III Original Soundtrack (#96313)

[Secret Squirrel]

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?lis...QVBCTf1MTWE3NY

@Eidolon2010

Your submission has been rejected.

Type: album edit
Reason: I checked your source, and those artists are not credited with any specific role for the tracks. For example, track 3 "プレリュード · Nobuo Uematsu · Nobuo Uematsu · 山中 康央", it seems just as possible that Yasuhiro Yamanaka is the Synthesizer Operator, for which he is already credited in the album liner notes. Without any more info from the Youtube videos, we can't say specifically what role they mean, and all artists are already credited in relevant roles.

If you feel the rejection is in error, please post further information or evidence here.

[Eidolon2010]

As far I know with YouTube videos uploaded like these, the credits always follow the same pattern in description:
"Title · Artist/Singer · Lyricist(if any) · Composer · Arranger"

But if you feel it's not fully accurate, I don't mind.

Though, Yamanaka was credited for "The Prelude" for FFIII DS, on https://vgmdb.net/album/89791

[yindesu]

I didn't submit the edit, but I've always taken issue with the way VGMdb interpreted the scans as I posted here - to the best of my knowledge, neither the muZik remix nor THE BLACK MAGES version appear in the game, so if Yasuhiro Yamanaka is muZik and is considered part of the game staff arrangers, then Kenichiro Fukui should be listed next to him.

However, Fukui is not listed as part of the game staff arrangers, so I'd take the NexTone/YouTube data I listed here at face value since it's consistent with what the scan says.

At the very least, I'd remove the suggestion that Yamanaka is responsible for the sound of the muZik remix, rather than the muZik unit itself, as there is no source that says muZik didn't arrange that remix.

[Secret Squirrel]

I'm actually not sure about the provenance of Keiji Kawamori (2~59), Yasuhiro Yamanaka (60). No track credits are given in the book. I'm going to ping @CHz , since best I can figure, it was part of the original page submission in 2006.

[CHz]

Unknown, possibly synthesized from the GMR entry which credited Yamanaka as the arranger of track 60. Feel free to blast it with prejudice

[Secret Squirrel]

@Eidolon2010

Based on discussion here, I've restored the Youtube info. I'll do it to the other album soon too, but I need to write some python and parse the json metadata from Mora as a double check.

[yindesu]

Square Enix did not upload arranger data to mora for this album. It's probably too old. (Similar to how ADA Japan is not currently uploading the same amount of data that Lantis used to, except the timeline is reversed.)